Editorials:
National Post, Toronto 2/17:
National Post View: The CP workers’ strike was none of the government’s business
Canada’s labour laws are absolutely clear: unions have the right to negotiate on behalf of their members and the power to walk off the job if their demands are not met. And as soon as they do — sometimes even before they do — the federal government can legislate them right back to work.
This odd incongruity was once again in evidence Tuesday when employees at Canadian Pacific Railway agreed to go back to work, in the shadow of planned federal legislation that would have forced them back. The 3,000 workers had been out less than two days after negotiations failed . . .
SNIP
While the government’s concern for the economy is laudable, it should not be used as an excuse for running roughshod over labour relations. While there are examples of essential services or national emergencies that might legitimately pre-empt the right to strike — . . . — it is a stretch to make that principle apply to a two-day-old strike at a private rail company. . . .
SNIP
Strikes are blunt instruments, and should be used only when talks have irrevocably failed. But they are legal, and a government that respects the law must respect that reality.
Read more here.
****************************************************************************
The Globe and Mail, Toronto 2/17:
Globe editorial
The blunt instrument of state-compelled back-to-workYet again, the Conservative government has shown its propensity to interventionism in the Canadian economy – an apparent deviation from its free-market principles. It’s almost as if the Conservatives had decided that certain federally regulated transportation companies are essential services.
Three successive federal labour ministers have either brought in back-to-work legislation or threatened to do so: . . .
Continue here.